Posts in category

State Your Case

State Your Case: Why MLB London Fletcher deserves a look

Read More

State Your Case: Why E.J. Holub and some AFL greats deserve consideration

Read More

State Your Case: Why former G Ed White deserves a look from the HOF

Read More

Evaluating the chances of former cornerback Champ Bailey making it to Canton as a first-ballot choice. in 2019

17 404

London Fletcher would play in four consecutive Pro Bowls before his streak ended in 2013 despite a team-leading 111 tackles. He retired after that season, having started the final 215 games of his career.

12 634

Until the advent of Robert Kraft’s New England Patriots, Carroll Rosenbloom was the winningest owner in NFL history. He created a franchise that didn’t exist in Baltimore and turned it into a three-time world champion and four-time NFL champion, then made one of the savviest “trades’’ in NFL history to take over the Los Angeles …

2 153

Remembering the greatness that was former linebacker George Webster.

2 132

E.J. Holub started 113 games in the 1960s as the Chiefs became the dominant team of the AFL era. The Chiefs won more games (87) and more championships (three) than any other team and played in the first two Super Bowls.

7 566

Darren Sharper ranks eighth all-time in inteceptions and third in non-offensive touchdowns scored. He was a serial disruptive for most of his 14-year career. He is also an admitted serial rapist jailed for 18 years. Must Hall of Fame voters ignore his crimes?

2 328

Why former Dallas safety Darren Woodson deserves to have his case heard by Pro Football Hall-of-Fame voters.

12 811

Ed White was a Pro Bowl blocker in one of the NFL’s top rushing offenses at Minnesota with Bill Brown, Dave Osborn and Chuck Foreman. He was one of only 10 players to participate in all four of Minnesota’s Super Bowls in the 1970s.

7 272

Nolan Cromwell was one of pro football’s all-time great safeties. So why isn’t he in the Hall of Fame discussion?

11 937

Why former NFL coach Chuck Knox deserves at least a look by Pro Football Hall-of-Fame voters.

1 125

Sample played his college football at Maryland Eastern Shore and, in 1958, became the first player from an historically black college (HBCU) invited to play in the College All-Star game against the defending NFL champion.

4 166

Rick Casares was a five-time Pro Bowl fullback in the days when that made you a beast. So why isn’t he also an NFL Hall of Famer?

3 313

Why former Rams’ quarterback Roman Gabriel deserves to have his case heard by Hall-of-Fame voters.

12 552

Jimmie Giles played 13 seasons and went to four Pro Bowls, catching 350 passes for 5,084 yards and 41 touchdowns. Those numbers pale in comparisons to the Rob Gronkowskis and Travis Kelces of today’s NFL. But that’s not what he was asked to do at his position in 1977.

3 209

“Whizzer” White was All-Pro every season he played in the NFL. Is the fact that was only three enough to keep him out of the Hall of Fame?

3 195