What don’t critics get about McNabb? Andy Reid knows


Clark Hunt, Andy Reid

(Photos courtesy of Kansas City Chiefs)

Talk of Fame Network

Boxer Bernard Hopkins is a local legend in Philadelphia, a popular guy who’s unafraid to say what he thinks. And what he’s thought for years is that former quarterback Donovan McNabb was not good for the Eagles … or, for that matter, any team he led.

Except he was.

He led the Eagles to five conference championship games in eight years, including four straight, and took them to their only Super Bowl since 1980. McNabb was one of the greatest quarterbacks in Philadelphia history, and if Hopkins can’t acknowledge it another notable Philadelphia personality can.

That’s former coach Andy Reid, now with Kansas City. The Eagles’ coach for a franchise-record 14 years, Reid told the Talk of Fame Network that if Hopkins only knew McNabb better he’d understand how valuable – or invaluable – he was to the Eagles franchise.

“I know Bernard,” said Reid on the latest TOF broadcast. “I had him speak to our team down there. Bernard knew how to play his game. His game. So he worked that thing the right way, kept himself in great shape and lasted a long time. I thought that’s what Donovan did with our game.

“That doesn’t always work out in certain people’s minds the right way. (But) to be a quarterback in this league you’ve got to be stuck in the middle in that locker room, looking at those guys, and at the same time be able to handle the head coach and management and so on. You’re juggling a lot of balls there, and so that’s a tough thing — a tremendously tough thing to do and do it well. I thought Donovan did that as well as anybody … and still went out and produced.

“I think if Bernard was on the team with Donovan, he would’ve seen the different parts of Donovan that he really didn’t know; (that) he just heard from people around. Donovan could be one of the guys. He knew how to do that. He was the funniest guy on the team. Clearly. So he knew when to loosen the guys up. And at the same time he knew how to tighten them up. He wasn’t afraid to get after you.

“He was not always the most popular guy, yet (he was) someone all the guys respected. Very few can carry that. I thought Bernard did the same thing in his business. It’s just a different dynamic boxing and football.“

Reid left Philadelphia in 2013 after having spending more time and winning more games than any coach in Eagles’ history. Staying anywhere 14 years is an accomplishment, but staying with a Philadelphia franchise that long is extraordinary – with Hall-of-Famer Greasy Neale (who spent 10 years with the Eagles) the closest to Reid.

“I loved it,” Reid said of his Philadelphia experience. “I loved the organization (and) I loved the people there. They are passionate. The thing they’re going to do. Is they’re going to show up. Win or lose they’re going to show up. They think a little bit like coaches do. If you stink they’re going to let you know you stink. If you do OK, they’re going to let you know you did OK. You can stink, and be OK in two plays. They take it play by play there.”

Previous Bears' Fox "excited" about what he's seen so far in Jay Cutler
Next State Your Case: Donnie Shell

1 Comment

  1. Rasputin
    April 27, 2017
    Reply

    Hogwash. The defense led that team to those conference championships, and McNabb is a big reason why they lost. His career passer rating in conference championship games was 72.2. He threw as many interceptions as TDs in those games.

    Andy Reid was a decent coach but he failed to win a Super Bowl because he wedded himself to the wrong QB for a decade and now of course he wants to spin it another way to cover his own butt. McNabb was always overrated. He only deserved to go to maybe 2 or 3 of those 6(!) Pro Bowls he was sent to. We’re talking about a guy whose career completion percentage was somehow BELOW THE LEAGUE AVERAGE FOR HIS ERA despite him largely just dumping the ball off in the regular season. Incredible. He’s also a terrible commentator now due to his general lack of intelligence. Hopefully he’s at least keeping up with the latest OT rules.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.