Who deserves the 2017 HOF contributor nomination?

Photo courtesy of Los Angeles Chargers
(Paul Tagliabue photo from the Talk of Fame Network files)
(Bobby Beathard photo courtesy of the Washington Redskins)

Talk of Fame Network

The Pro Football Hall of Fame introduced a contributor category in 2015, and all three of the candidates nominated since then have been enshrined in Canton: General managers Bill Polian and Ron Wolf in 2015 and owner Eddie DeBartolo Jr. in 2016.

The new category opened the door to deserving candidates who previously faced long odds for enshrinement. There will be two such contributor candidates for the Class of 2017. That’s the subject of this week’s Talk of Fame Network poll — who is most deserving of that nomination? Here are your candidates:

Bobby Beathard. Beathard was a talent evaluator extraordinaire, helping build championship teams in three cities – Kansas City (1966), Miami (1972-73) and Washington (1981, 1987). He also built a fourth franchise into a Super Bowl team – the 1994 San Diego Chargers, who lost to the 49ers in the championship game. Beathard served as a scout in Kansas City, the director of player personnel at Miami and the general manager of both the Redskins and Chargers. Three of his Washington draft picks are in the Hall of Fame: Darrell Green, Russ Grimm and Art Monk.  Beathard retired from the Chargers and the NFL in 2000.  

Jerry Jones. The flamboyant owner of the Cowboys owns three Super Bowl rings and the most valuable sporting franchise in the world. He changed the way NFL teams market themselves, introducing stadium revenue streams that put millions of dollars into the pockets of owners and players. He built the league’s first billion-dollar stadium, and the revenues generated from all these new buildings have been a principal reason the salary cap has skyrocketed from $34.6 million in 1994 to $155.27 million in 2016. Jones has served two tenures on the NFL competition committee and brokered the deal that moved the Rams back to Los Angeles for the 2016 season.

Bucko Kilroy. Along the lines of a Dick LeBeau and John Madden, Kilroy is a “body-of-work” candidate. He arrived in the NFL as a player in 1943 and wound up as an all-decade selection for the 1940s as an offensive tackle with the Eagles. He went on to spend 45 years as an NFL executive and talent evaluator with the Redskins, Cowboys and Patriots. As general manager of the Patriots in the 1980s, he built a team that went to the franchise’s first Super Bowl. As the team’s head of scouting in the 2000s, he was responsible for many of the players who won three Super Bowls for the Patriots from 2001-04. Kilroy passed away at the age of 86 in 2007.

Bucko Kilroy

(Bucko Kilroy photo courtesy of the New England Patriots)

Steve Sabol. Steve’s father Ed has already been enshrined in Canton for creating NFL Films, which accelerated the national popularity of pro football in the 1960s. But Steve was the creative genius behind the brand with cutting edge filmwork that gave faces and personalities to the men behind the facemasks. Steve won more than 40 Emmys during his career and received the Lifetime Achievement Award in 2003 from the National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences for “revolutionizing the way America watches football and setting the standard in sports filmmaking.” Sabol passed away in 2012 at the age of 69.


(Steve Sabol photo courtesy of NFL Films)

Paul Tagliabue. The successor to Hall-of-Fame commissioner Pete Rozelle, Tagliabue served in the capacity for 17 years, during which the league expanded from 28 to 32 teams and saw 18 new stadiums built.  There were no labor stoppages during his term and both free agency and a salary cap were implemented. The NFL also increased its international presence during Tagliabue’s term, starting a spring league in Europe and playing exhibition games in Australia, Canada, Germany, Ireland, Japan, Mexico, Spain and Sweden. Tagliabue retired from the NFL in 2006.

Vote now!

[socialpoll id=”2373984″]

Previous Why isn't Jerry Kramer in the HOF?
Next The one guy Jim Kelly would like to see in the HOF? Kent Hull


  1. bachslunch
    August 10, 2016

    Definitely yes to Sabol, Beathard, George Young, Gil Brandt, and Art McNally. Maybe on Tagilabue, won’t squawk if he gets in. Not big on most of the remaining owners– the best left are probably Jerry Jones, Robert Kraft, or Carroll Rosenbloom. Kind of on the fence on Kilroy and Joe Thomas.

  2. Richard D Quodomine
    August 10, 2016

    I can’t evaluate Kilroy – the resume is there, but I don’t know enough and maybe there’s something to be said for fame. But lack of flamboyance doesn’t make him a poor choice, either. I’d defer to others who know his work better.

    I’m a Bills fan, so I’m going to pass on giving Jerry Jones any grade. I’m biased against him.

    Beathard has the Leaf albatross around his neck, which is a shame, because the rest of his resume sparkles. He should be in.

    Tags is a yes. He built the league to its modern heights, and built it on solid ground.

    I voted for Sabol. If Rozelle and Tags ran the restaurant competently, then its chef and most valued face was Sabol – he was not only good at producing films, but his narration and talent for explanation – never talking down but still educating, always was good. I felt smarter every time I watched something from “NFL Films Presents…” and I watched that show religiously on Sundays …. His intelligence and clear passion for the game is part of the reason I can watch another wretched season from the Bills and still love the game.

  3. Mark Schneider
    August 10, 2016

    Not trying to annoy but- SENIOR COMMITTEE PLEASE- there is only 1 candidate head and shoulders above the others. #1 Senior candidate is JERRY KRAMER. JERRY KRAMER. JERRY KRAMER

  4. Beathard, George Young, Gil Brandt, and Art McNally. Maybe on Tagilabue, won’t squawk if he gets in. Not big on most of the remaining owners– the best left are probably Jerry Jones, Robert Kraft, or Carroll Rosenbloom. Kind of on the fence on Kilroy and Joe Thomas.

  5. Robert Ewing
    August 12, 2016

    I would be ok with if they went with young and beathard as contributor nominees

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.