Why the Need for a Senior Committee


By Rick Gosselin

Talk of Fame Network

Jack Butler is the only player in NFL history to average at least one defensive takeaway every two games.

Butler played defensive back for the Pittsburgh Steelers for nine seasons in the 1950s, intercepting 52 passes and recovering 10 fumbles in 103 career games. He was named to the 1960s NFL all-decade team. He also was one of only three cornerbacks named to the NFL’s 50th anniversary team.

Yet Butler had to wait 50 years to be discussed and debated for the very first time as a Hall of Fame finalist. That came in 2012 and Butler was promptly elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Sadly, he passed away less than nine months later at the age of 85.

Players like Jack Butler are the reason the Pro Football Hall of Fame has a senior committee.

My Talk of Fame Sports Network compadre Ron Borges and I both serve on that nine-member committee. It’s our task to find the players who have slipped through the cracks of the selection process. Our committee is allowed to nominate one senior candidate this year. The committee will meet on Wednesday (Aug. 20) to select that candidate for the Class of 2015.

When a player retires, he faces a five-year waiting period before becoming eligible for enshrinement. Then he has a 20-year window of eligibility as a modern-era candidate. If that player does not gain enshrinement during those 25 years, he becomes a senior candidate.

Everyone in the senior pool is a longshot for Canton.

Every NFL franchise believes it has 2-3 players who have not received a fair shake from the selection process. For Dallas, it’s Drew Pearson, Harvey Martin and Cliff Harris. For Kansas City, it’s Otis Taylor, Johnny Robinson and Ed Budde. For Oakland it’s Ken Stabler, Cliff Branch and Todd Christensen.

There are 26 established franchises, so that’s a pool of about 75 worthy senior candidates right there. But our committee can resurrect the candidacies of only one player this year and two the next.

When I was appointed to the committee in 2004, I spent about two weeks compiling a list of players I believed to be worthy of senior consideration — players who made all-decade teams, who went to multi-Pro Bowls, who were NFL MVPs and individual statistical champions.

My initial list included about 80 such players. There was a common thread. Many of them were defensive players who didn’t win championships. Like Jack Butler. And Les Richter. And Dick LeBeau.

Richter went to eight Pro Bowls in his nine seasons with the Rams. The only season he missed was his final season in 1962 when team injuries forced him to move to center. He also was the placekicker for a Rams team that reached the 1955 NFL title game.

Richter waited 46 years to be discussed as a finalist for the first time in 2011 as a senior candidate. He was elected to the Hall of Fame but the honor came posthumously. He passed away in 2010 at the age of 79.

LeBeau ranks third among pure cornerbacks with 62 interceptions for the Detroit Lions. He waited 33 years to be discussed for the first time as a finalist. He was enshrined in the Class of 2010.

Dave Robinson waited 34 years to be discussed as a finalist for the first time. Chris Hanburger waited 28 years for his first turn in the room and Curley Culp 27. All were enshrined.

There are too many quality players who have never even been discussed as finalists. The senior committee exists to remind them they have not been forgotten.

Follow Rick Gosselin on Twitter at @RickGosselinDMN

Butler_Jack (1)

Courtesy of the Pittsburgh Steelers

Previous Five camps we wish never closed
Next Willie Lanier Interview 8-15-14

2 Comments

  1. August 18, 2014
    Reply

    As a Longtime Detroit Lions fan, PLEASE consider Alex Karras in the same light as the HOF players you discussed in your article. If Warren Sapp is a 1st ballot HOF with Brooks, Lynch & possibly soon Barber behind him, then Karras who had Lary, Lane, Schmidt, Lebeau & even Barney become HOF’s is very worthy of this honor too.
    He was also a decade player facing Kramer most the time giving him all he could handle. As well, he was the force behind the ORIGINAL Fearsome Foursome that had Roger Brown next to him (traded to the Rams & took the name with him). Any clips you see generally is what you see Sapp, Joe Green & today even Suh, McCoy & Atkins do now.
    Detroit sports writers I understand for some reason are NOT represented in the voting process let alone the Senior process. I’ve talked with Gil Brandt about him & Alex Marvez on occasion.
    I sincerely hope his 1 year suspension is not holding him back, since Hornung is now in that prestigious Hall. It’s a shame too that he has passed, a true maverick & throwback football player that would be ruled out o the game today.
    I grew up watching him as a kid, and hope to see The Mad Duck awarded this honor soon.
    Thank you.
    Brandon.

    • Rick Gosselin
      August 18, 2014
      Reply

      If you watched the 1962 Thanksgiving against the Packers, Karras would already be in. Hard for me to believe he’s never even been discussed as a finalist.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.