Why We Watch: It’s not Brady-Manning but it is a QB duel

25 August 2016: Ryan Russell (99) of the Dallas Cowboys during their 27-17 loss to the Seattle Seahawks at CenturyLink Field in Seattle, Washington. Photo by James D. Smith/Dallas Cowboys

By Clark Judge

Talk of Fame Network



The line: Cowboys by 4-1/2

The weather: Sunny, high of 88 (retractable roof)

Aug 11, 2016; Philadelphia, PA, USA; at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: John Geliebter-Philadelphia Eagles
Aug 11, 2016; Philadelphia, PA, USA; at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: John Geliebter-Philadelphia Eagles

The story: Philadelphia’s Jordan Matthews says that Carson Wentz-Dak Prescott could be the new Manning-Brady, and he’s right. It could be. But it’s not. Not yet. And not for a long, long time. Manning and Brady have been to nine Super Bowls and are among the best quarterbacks ever. Wentz and Prescott aren’t among the best quarterbacks now.

As I said, they could be. But they’re not.

So let’s forget about the quarterbacks and concentrate on what matters. most And what matters for the NFL is this: This game goes head-to-head with the World Series, which means we gain another barometer on TV ratings. Yeah, this is an attractive matchup, but so is Cubs-Indians … especially if Game 5 decides the Series.

For Philadelphia, of course, what matters is pretty simple: Stop Ezekiel Elliott and make the next Tom Brady … er, make Dak Prescott … beat you. If not, you force Wentz to play from behind, and we saw how that worked in Detroit. Let’s just say he looked like neither Manning or Brady.

Hall-of-Fame worthy: Philadelphia is 5-2 at AT&T Stadium since it opened in 2009, the best record of any Dallas opponent. The Eagles won their last three there.



The line: Falcons by 3

The weather: Dome

mattryanThe story: The Falcons lost their last two, but Atlanta coach Dan Quinn insists this is not last year’s club. He better hope not. Last year’s club started 5-0, then cratered — dropping eight of its last 11. That team would lose this game. This team could. The Falcons lead the league in offense, and Matt Ryan will get some mid-season MVP votes, but their defense can leak like the S.S. Minnow … and that’s not good when Aaron Rodgers is next on the schedule. One problem: Aaron Rodgers doesn’t look like Aaron Rodgers, and everyone wants to know why. The clues start here.

Hall-of-Fame worthy: Ryan has thrown for 300 yards in four of his last five home starts.

(Matt Ryan photo courtesy of Atlanta Falcons)

The line: Patriots by 6

The weather: AM showers, high of 52

The story: This one is simple. It’s payback time. New England has only one loss this year, and it was to Buffalo. And it was no ordinary loss. The Patriots were shut out for the first time ever at Gillette Stadium … and it happened after a pre-game skirmish. Of course, that was without Tom Brady, but bottom line: They lost. So now what? Well, so now Brady is back, and he’s 25-3 vs. the Bills. And so Bill Belichick has no use for Rex Ryan, just as Rex has no use for Bill. Brady is on a mission. The Patriots are on a mission. LeSean McCoy may not play. Aaron Williams definitely won’t play. Belichick has a long memory. And Buffalo can’t stop running backs like LeGarrette Blount (think Jay Ajayi). Connect the dots, people: Going to be a different result this time around.

Hall-of-Fame worthy: New England has not been swept in the last 15 years by anyone.

SAN DIEGO @ DENVER, 4:05 p.m. (EDT)

The line: Broncos by 4-1/2

The weather: Partly cloudy, high of 81

The story: The Chargers believe they turned their season around with their last two games – both victories – and they may be right. Here’s where we find out. That streak started with a defeat of the Broncos two Thursdays ago, and it catapulted San Diego to an overtime defeat of the Falcons last weekend. Both those victories were upsets, and the Bolts aren’t expected to win this one, either. But careful: Philip Rivers is on fire, Melvin Gordon leads the league in TDs and Joey Bosa has pumped life into a defense that just subtracted end Caraun Reid. Yeah, I know, the Denver defense just shut down Brock Osweiler, but this is no Brock Osweiler coming to town. Plus, cornerback Aqib Talib is hurt. If the Chargers lose, they will do it as they have too many times this season: They will beat themselves.

Hall-of-Fame worthy: In his last 11 games vs. San Diego, Von Miller has 12 sacks, 14 tackles for losses and three forced fumbles.



The line: Vikings by 4-1/2

The weather: Partly cloudy, high of 68

jay-cutler-chicago-bearsThe story: Jay Cutler is back, and that’s supposed to make a difference. But who’s kidding whom? Chicago fans are pumped up, all right, but it has nothing to do with Cutler and everything to do with Schwarber … and Rizzo … and Lester. They like their Cubs. They don’t like their Bears, and can you blame them? They stink, ranking 31st in points and 27th in touchdowns, and they’re at or near the bottom in local interest. There’s little to like about this club except where it drafts next spring. And that includes Mr. Personality, Cutler, who returns in time to face the league’s top-ranked defense and a pass rush that sacked Cam Newton eight times.

Hall-of-Fame worthy: Chicago’s Alshon Jeffrey averages 108.8 yards receiving in his last five games vs. Minnesota, with five touchdown catches.

(Jay Cutler photo courtesy of the Chicago Bears)


Clark Judge – Minnesota (– 4-1/2). It’s the Bears, stupid.

Ron Borges – Oakland (Even). Raiders on the road again. Ten days in Florida will focus the mind.

Rick Gosselin – Cleveland (+3). The Browns are celebrating the 30th anniversary of their 1986 team that reached the AFC championship game, and then-coach Marty Schottenheimer will be present. This would be the proper time for Cleveland’s first win of the season.


DETROIT QB MATT STAFFORD. With a game-winning drive in the fourth quarter Sunday vs. Houston, he ties Peyton Manning and Jake Plummer for the second-most (25) of such drives in a quarterback’s first eight seasons since 1970. Only Matt Ryan (30) has more.

ATLANTA QB MATT RYAN. With 406 yards passing vs. Green Bay he passes Philip Rivers (2,753) for the second-most yards passing through the first eight games of a season.

CINCINNATI QB ANDY DALTON. He aims for his fifth straight game with a passer rating of 100 or better and non interceptions.

SAN DIEGO QB PHILIP RIVERS. His next 300-yard game will be the 50th of his career.

SAN DIEGO RB MELVIN GORDON. If he scores twice Sunday, he ties the franchise record for most touchdowns (12) through the first eight games in franchise history, set by LaDainian Tomlinson.

DALLAS RB EZEKIEL ELLIOTT. Through his first six games he has 707 yards rushing, second only to Eric Dickerson (787) for a rookie. With 130 yards rushing vs. Philadelphia he would become only the seventh player in league history to rush for 130 or more yards in five consecutive games.


WASHINGTON QB KIRK COUSINS. He has a passer rating of 100 or better in five of his last six road games.

HOUSTON QB BROCK OSWEILER. He’s 4-0 as a starter at home.

INDIANAPOLIS Q ANDREW LUCK. He’s thrown for 300 or more yards in his last five of his last six home games.

NEW ORLEANS QB DREW BREES. He averages 403.4 yards per game in his last five at home, throwing for 17 touchdowns with just two interceptions.

SAN DIEGO TE ANTONIO GATES. He has four TDs in his last five starts vs. Denver.

ATLANTA WR JULIO JONES. He averages 9-plus catches and 140-yards in four of his last five at home.


The Philadelphia Eagles outscore opponents 86-26 in the second half, including 60-6 in the third quarter.

The Chiefs lead the league in opponents’ passer rating at 52.9.

The Eagles have 10 sacks on first downs, most in the NFL.

Indianapolis, Oakland and Washington lead the league in forced fumbles with nine each.

Minnesota’s defensive linemen have combined for 17 sacks, most in the NFL for that position.

Minnesota’s opponents have a passer rating of 30.1 on third downs, lowest in the league. Oakland is next at 61.8.

Arizona has not allowed a touchdown in the last 11 quarters.



Previous McGinest, Lomas Brown discuss Super Bowls and HOF resumes; Haley talks Steelers and Big Ben
Next Judgements: That should end the debate; Big D stands for Dak


  1. Rasputin
    October 29, 2016

    Y’all should do a write up on why people don’t watch, acknowledging the significantly declining NFL ratings this year. An honest assessment would focus on people’s disgust with the anti-American anthem protests, and would be appropriate here since Ron Borges already wrote that favorable piece on Kaepernick a couple of months ago. From what I’ve seen national sports media commentators have been strenuously dismissing the notion that the protests have had any negative impact on ratings. It’s amazing watching liberal ESPN anchors constantly all agree with each other on what are supposed to be “debate” shows the frequent times they get into political issues, but the evidence shows how divorced from reality they are. This scientific Suffolk University poll found respondents cited the backlash against the anthem protests as the #1 reason for falling ratings.
    An outright majority (56%) cited it as a factor. I wish the sports media was more honest.

    • Rasputin
      October 29, 2016

      Excuse me, I meant a Seton Hall University poll.

      • October 29, 2016

        I might have to change the name of this column to Why We DONT Watch.

  2. Rich Quodomine
    October 30, 2016

    I’m going to throw a flag of caution – not rejection – on the Seton Hall poll. Here’s the question they asked:

    A Seton Hall Sports Poll conducted this week asked people to identify factors accounting for the drop [in ratings] (From here: http://blogs.shu.edu/sportspoll/2016/10/27/nfl-tv-ratings-down-fans-cite-a-host-of-factors-led-by-national-anthem-protests/)

    Each question was asked separately, allowing for a yes, no or don’t know response. Thus, respondents could weigh in on each of the seven possibilities as a contributing factor without identifying one single factor

    So, this asked the question of the fans why they thought or felt the ratings were declining. It did not ask the following “normalizing questions”:
    “Do you watch more or less football?”
    “If you watch more/less, why?” with the same questions as the original 7.

    The poll should also ask racial and income normalizing questions. It would be interesting, regarding Kaepernick, if for example, more white people or black people felt the game was losing viewership due to the Kaepernick situation. Again, I’m not denying that the whole Kaepernick thing may be an issue. I am saying the poll didn’t go far enough and any poll of opinion as to why something occurs needs normalizing questions. And yes, I’ve been doing stats analysis for 20 years, so I’m not talking out of my hat here. I’m not denying that he’s an issue in why some people may or may not watch. I’m saying I want more out of this poll before we declare it to be causative.

    • Rasputin
      October 30, 2016

      No poll asks every potential interesting question, and no one denies there is likely more than one reason for declining ratings (hence the poll’s format), but that respondents cited it as the #1 reason is strong evidence it’s on people’s minds and that most people in the general population think it’s a factor in the ratings plunge. That’s worth noting when I’ve seen hacks on ESPN assert with certainty that the fall in ratings is about the election or other factors and has absolutely nothing to do with the anthem protests, their dismissals being based on no evidence whatsoever, and likely motivated by the ratings story being inconvenient to their political narrative. Here is empirical evidence that they’re wrong. It also underscores that the views of typical fans aren’t currently being reflected in or even really covered by the biased national sports media. That’s a festering scandal in and of itself.

  3. Rich Quodomine
    October 30, 2016

    But that’s just it – it is empirical evidence, which is necessary but not sufficient, because it’s a poll of opinions that ask the subject what they think it is. It’s a good start for further research and the basis for a hypothesis, and I’m not denying that. If the ratings remain down after the election, then we’ve got 2 results indicating that the NFL product is down without viewing competition in the WS and from the election. That would remove the competition factor. Then you look at the grounds, and you dig further with the questions I suggested. You may very well be correct, Rasputin. I’m just saying, on a statistical basis, there’s not causation or proof, yet. I want to look further and deeper.

  4. Rasputin
    October 30, 2016

    But you’re ignoring the point about sports media bias. There’s significantly more evidence at this point supporting the position that the anthem protests are impacting ratings than there is supporting the assertion that they aren’t. Don’t you agree that national outlets like ESPN should be covering things like this poll and the views of millions of outraged Americans, acknowledging the possible tie, rather than dismissing any connection between ratings and the protests on the rare occasions they even mention the two items in the same segment? Heck, I’ve seen multiple online articles from major “news” outlets in recent weeks talking about the ratings decline and I don’t recall any of them mentioning the anthem protests, aside from a few conservative media watchdog sites. That the comments sections in these mainstream liberal “news” articles are always dominated by posts focusing on the anthem protests shows how surreal the media pretense is. They’ve mentioned a slew of other possibilities that vary in absurdity, a few of which (like the election) interestingly tied for last or near last in this poll. I haven’t really heard a good explanation for why the election would keep people from watching football on Sunday, though it’s easy to see how disgust with an apparently two faced, anti-American league can cause people to tune out. After all, some things are more important than football.
    Much was made by the media about Kaepernick’s jersey sales spiking, it was practically celebrated, but the fact that many people were buying them to burn them or otherwise show their displeasure with him, even in San Francisco, received less coverage.
    I would have seriously considered tuning out myself if my team, the Dallas Cowboys, hadn’t been representing themselves so well on these issues and making me proud to be a Cowboys fan.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.